When Are Two Starts Not Two Starts?

By Andrew Reilly

Today’s Sun-Times posits Sox starter Jake Peavy has not just declared but also proven himself worthy of playing with the big kids in the American League. How has he done this? Guns blazing, that’s how:

Just in case one more statement needs to be made, Jake Peavy hopes to make it with his start Friday.

His wish is that the game still will mean something for the Detroit Tigers in the American League Central race. But even if it doesn’t, Peavy would like to end the perception that he originally turned down the trade from the San Diego Padres in May because he was worried about a skyrocketing ERA in the AL — just in case his 2-0 record and 2.25 ERA in his first two starts aren’t enough proof.

First things first: Peavy is a good pitcher, possibly even a great pitcher. Everyone knows this, and while the NL-to-AL adjustment has never been kind to even the best of talented arms, even a Peavy taken down a peg was (and is) reason for great hope on the South Side.

But to call a Cy Young winner shutting down the dregs of the American League as some kind of declaration of awesomeness is almost an insult to Peavy himself. Wait until he matches up against the Yankees, or the Red Sox, or any non-joke of a team because here’s another statement: the Royals and Tigers are garbage.

Peavy held the Royals to three runs? That’s great. So did Todd Wellemeyer, Trevor Cahill and Matt Albers.

In all fairness, Peavy did shut out the Detroit Tigers (correction: division-leading Detroit Tigers!), and this grace under pressure should bode well for No. 44’s American League future, shouldn’t it? Of course it should, just as it did for fellow Tiger slayers Carl “1.35 WHIP” Pavano and Phil “lost my spot in the rotation” Hughes.

All told, it’s not just a bogus assertion but a dismissive one as well; two garbage-time starts’ worth of Jake Peavy mean nothing just yet, especially against the backdrop of his less-than-stellar splits away from his old stomping ground. Common sense and all the available signs indicate he will do just fine, but to say he’s already established himself would mean we, not unlike reporter Cowley and the team he covers, have simply given up.

blog comments powered by Disqus
Popular Tags
Chicago Bears
Chicago Cubs
Chicago White Sox
MLB
NBA
NFL
Media
Video
Recent Posts
Bo Knows Pimped Out Golf Carts
The Saints Show Their Super Bowl Rings
Seabrook’s Quest For Two More Cups
Patrick Kane’s Drunken Blur Of A Week
Kris Versteeg Raps Again
Wally Backman Knows How To Get Ejected With Style
A Look At The Blackhawks Parade
Kane Boozes, Roenick Cries and the Hawks Hoist the Cup
Archives
  • June 2010
  • May 2010
  • April 2010
  • March 2010
  • February 2010
  • January 2010
  • December 2009
  • November 2009
  • October 2009
  • September 2009
  • August 2009
  • July 2009
  • Blog Search

    About | Feed
    MOUTHPIECE Blog is a Chicago-centric sports blog which will also comment on national stories and general sports blog-y goodness. If you wish to contact us please email our Executive Producer Brian Dryfhout at bdryfhout@mouthpiecesports.com

    Subscribe to our RSS feed.
    Blogroll
    | Awful Announcing | Ball Don’t Lie | Ballhype | Bricks & Ivy | Can’t Stop the Bleeding | Deadspin | Detroit Bad Boys | Docksquad Sports | EDSBS | FanHouse | Foxy Frenzy | Free Darko | Inside the Hall | Kissing Suzy Kolber | Larry Brown Sports | Mister Irrelevant | NBA Mock Drafts Database | Shutdown Corner | Sports by Brooks | Storming the Floor | The Dagger | The Sporting Blog | True Hoop | With Leather .