Baseball’s Curious Anti-Replay Logic

By Ryan Corazza

Hey, who wants to talk about instant replay some more today? This guy does!

So, remember how there were a bunch of terrible calls in the MLB playoffs this year and everyone complained about it? Also: remember how Alex Rodriguez hit a home run that happened to bounce off a camera in right field, so it looked like it wasn’t a home run, and he was only rewarded with a double? But then remember how the umps went to check the replay — because in baseball, this is the only thing you can review via instant replay — and they overturned the call to a home run, because it was actually a home run? See how instant replay can lead to the right call?

Well, baseball has its general managers meeting out at O’Hare this week, and expanded instant replay was quickly cast aside:

“The commissioner is a very forward-looking person, but he has an ample respect for tradition,” said Solomon. “He doesn’t take this lightly. He doesn’t make a lot of changes in the game without giving it a complete vetting.”

Solomon said the only discussion on instant replay Tuesday concerned the present system.

“We only have a season and a couple of months’ experience with instant replay,” said Solomon. “Now there are those who clamor for more.”

Asked if there would be more discussion at the winter meetings, Solomon said, “Right now the commissioner doesn’t see any reason to consider it.”

This is to be expected. As I’ve written before, baseball is a game that adheres to tradition, that adheres to good ‘ol Americana. And that means expanded instant replay isn’t just going to happen overnight. We still might be years away. But at some point in the future, it’s likely going to happen. And wrong calls will be corrected more often than not.

blog comments powered by Disqus
Popular Tags
Chicago Bears
Chicago Cubs
Chicago White Sox
MLB
NBA
NFL
Media
Video
Recent Posts
Should Bulls Be Pinning Hopes On A Tracy McGrady Deal?
Would Brett Favre Have Made Super-Bowl Viewership Even Higher?
Video: Best Super Bowl Commercials
Everybody’s Blogging For The Weekend: Super Bowlin’
Bears ‘Hire’ Defensive Coordinator. It’s Rod Marinelli.
Lou On Zambrano: ‘He Looks Absolutely Wonderful’
Devin Hester Wants To Return The Ball More
Uh Oh: Bulls Possibly Shutting Down Joakim Noah Through All-Star Break? (UPDATE)
Archives
  • February 2010
  • January 2010
  • December 2009
  • November 2009
  • October 2009
  • September 2009
  • August 2009
  • July 2009
  • June 2009
  • May 2009
  • April 2009
  • March 2009
  • Blog Search

    Staff
    Sole Proprietor:
    Ryan Corazza | E-mail
    About | Feed
    MOUTHPIECE Blog is a Chicago-centric sports blog which will also comment on national stories and general sports blog-y goodness. E-mail rcorazza at mouthpiecesports dot com with tips and story ideas, if you so desire.

    Subscribe to our RSS feed.
    Blogroll
    | Awful Announcing | Ball Don’t Lie | Ballhype | Blog Chicago Sports | Can’t Stop the Bleeding | Dan Shanoff | Dave’s Football Blog | Deadspin | Detroit Bad Boys | Docksquad Sports | EDSBS | FanHouse | Free Darko | Inside the Hall | Kissing Suzy Kolber | Larry Brown Sports | Mister Irrelevant | NBA Mock Drafts Database | Shutdown Corner | Sports by Brooks | Storming the Floor | The Dagger | The Sporting Blog | True Hoop | With Leather .